VANCOUVER, Canada – When we woke up in the morning, the TransCanada had already heaved itself over the highest point in the Rockies.
Gone were the dense forests of the East. Gone were the wide-open spaces of Saskatchewan and Alberta. We were in British Columbia – rolling downhill, following the gray-green river downstream, through boiling canyons and lazy flats…
Does any country have more bountiful natural resources than Canada?
Timber, food, cattle, minerals, water – Canadians have it all.
Too bad: When it comes to prosperity, there are few things as dangerous as inheriting money or having abundant natural resources.
Gagging on Oil
Rather than making or inventing things… or providing useful services… a resource-rich economy tends to sell itself – by the ton.
When commodities boom, the miners, farmers, and lumberjacks live high on the hog. But when they fall – the economy falls with them.
Canada’s economic growth was negative in the first quarter. The country is the world’s tenth largest exporter of crude oil. And oil is in its worst downturn in 30 years, according to Morgan Stanley.
The U.S. oil price has dipped below $50 a barrel. Along with it, the entire commodity complex – upon which much of the economy of Canada depends – could be dragged further down too.
Even more dangerous than resource abundance is economic “guidance” from the feds.
First, Alan Greenspan kept rates too low after the mini-recession of 2001. Then the Bernanke Fed pushed them down to near zero and kept them there for the last six years. And now Janet Yellen is steering the same course.
The cheap credit gave resource producers the means to overproduce and consumers the wherewithal to over consume.
At such a low cost of borrowing, producers could earn positive cash flow without regard to real economic results. And with the Fed’s rate fixing falsifying the cost of capital, they didn’t know if they were really making money or not.
So, they produced so much oil the world gagged on it.
Commodities Give Way
But now the bottom has given way under the resource market. (Scroll down to Market Insight for more…)
BHP Billiton, the world’s largest mining company by reserves, has slashed production…
…Caterpillar – which pushes lifts and carries resources all over the world – has seen sales falling for 31 months in a row…
…Chesapeake Energy – the tenth largest oil producer and second largest natural gas producer in the U.S. – has cut its dividend to preserve cash, as shares fell to a 12-year low…
…and Kumba Iron Ore, Africa’s largest iron ore producer, has eliminated its dividend after announcing that profits had crashed 66% in the first half of the year.
None of this is good news for Canada’s commodity-based economy.
But there’s something else going on here…
Life in Canada’s cities is different from the countryside. An influx of immigrants, mostly from Asia, has boosted the energy and wealth of Toronto, Vancouver, and other large urban areas.
They seem more prosperous and dynamic than the large metropolises of the U.S. For the most part, property prices are higher in Canada, too – especially in Vancouver – where they may be more a product of foreign buying than of local industry.
Outside the cities, though, you might just as well be in West Virginia, Oklahoma, or Alabama. There is little evidence of wealth or style.
Along the tracks of the TransCanada, our only reference, houses are modest – even shabby.
Neither agriculture nor forestry appears to have ever produced much profit for Canada’s heartland.
Particularly disappointing is the domestic architecture. A dear reader sent a photo (see today’s Mailbag below) of a house he had built with his own hands – of stone and logs. It is a gem. But it is unusual.
Whether you are in the outer suburbs of Toronto… or out on the plains of Alberta… the style is the same: boxy, boring, and cheap.
But when we rolled into Vancouver, all of a sudden, things changed.
We saw money. There are high-rise condos everywhere. Chic people. Expensive shops. Crowded restaurants.
A few years ago, a bust in the mining sector would have emptied the restaurants. Today, the waiters keep serving drinks despite the smashup in the resource sector.
Back in the old days, a collapse in mining meant that brokers, promoters, and mining entrepreneurs – not to mention the stockholders – had to move fast to raise cash.
Their fancy cars went back to the dealers, and real estate agents put up “For Sale” signs in front of their handsome houses!
No evidence of that now.
Compared to incomes, Vancouver has the second most expensive houses in the world. Only Hong Kong has less affordable real estate.
Advice to Canadian readers: Sell.
Postscript: After four days on the rails, the TransCanada eased into Vancouver station. Luggage was off-loaded. Cabin stewards were thanked. We had become friendly with our travel companions and embraced them warmly as we headed in our separate directions.
We don’t know if we’d do it again, but it was a pleasure doing it once. Canada is a magnificent country. We were glad we got a chance to see it.
We took photos… Scroll to the end and have a look.
Today’s chart says it all…
It looks at the Thomson Reuters/CoreCommodity CRB Index versus the S&P 500 going back 10 years.
The CRB Index tracks prices of 19 of the most commonly traded commodities. These include aluminum, coffee, copper, crude oil, gold, natural gas, silver, and wheat.
Since the most recent peak in the commodities market in April 2011, the CRB Index and the S&P 500 have dramatically diverged.
Over that time, the CRB Index has plummeted 44%. And the S&P 500 has gained 54%.
Energy Junk Bonds Are Getting Slammed
Bond investors should be paying close attention to what’s happening in the energy patch. Thanks to the big slide in commodities, junk bonds have lost over 12% this year.
Why the U.S. Dollar Could Be Replaced as Early as This Fall
Currencies expert Jim Rickards is back from an “invitation only” meeting with officials from the Pentagon, the CIA, and the U.S. director of intelligence. What he learned may shock you…
Here’s How Gold Gets to $800 an Ounce
According to Morgan Stanley, in the worst-case scenario gold could tumble all the way to $800 an ounce. All that’s needed is another stock correction in China and a rate hike in the U.S.
Lots of comments on Bill’s train journey across Canada…
Thanks for the great articles…
“Hormegeddon” affects Canada too. I share your concern with the efficiency of VIA Rail Canada. It runs like a socialist railway – late, with impaired services. (I have used it from Toronto to Montreal.)
Here is some non-vinyl-clad house my son and I built – using mostly a chain saw and an adze – took us seven years part-time with rocks and timber off the property.
Our friends thought we were nuts for not just going to the lumber store – some people do it the old-fashioned way.
– Frank F.
Dear wandering friends, I encourage you to make your trip again in November through March. Canada is beautiful, and very, very cold in the winter. The growing seasons are short, as are the construction (houses, offices, roads) and traveling seasons.
Go to Fairbanks or some of our other Alaskan cities, NOT on the coast, where they benefit from the Japan Current. Sitka, for example, has about the same snowfall and temperature as Nashville, Tennessee, due to the Japan Current.
But those interior cities are small or nonexistent. Due to weather and mountains, there are no roads to the capital city of Juneau.
Do not judge books by their covers, nor northern cities by a few buildings you see from a train. The people are great, and so are the warm interiors of their homes.
– Carl M.
My first view of Canada was flying into Abbotsford for the annual air show in a Navy E-2C Hawkeye. Your descriptions have captured the essence of the geography perfectly. Can’t wait until you give feedback on Vancouver.
During our air show stay, we drove into Vancouver and were enthralled with the restaurants, nightlife, and overall positive energy of the people and city. Hope you have as wonderful a time as we did.
– Pete R.
Bill reckons the Canadian real estate market is heading for a bust. Do you live in Canada? Do you agree that prices are bound to fall?
Write to Bill and the team at [email protected]
Bill’s Photos of Canada